Aerial view of the north end of Captiva Island, with waterfront condos and a golf course between Pine Island Sound and the Gulf of Mexico
Lee County, Florida

Sanibel and Captiva Housing Markets

Prices, selling time and homes for sale on Sanibel and on Captiva, each reported on its own, with the repair, elevation, insurance and rental checks that matter on the islands. From the Worthington Realty research team.

Southwest Florida › Sanibel and Captiva

October 2026 · Updated Nov. 5, 2026

Sanibel and Captiva Home Prices and Market Numbers

Sanibel Median, Aug–Oct

$925,000

Up 15.6% vs. last year

Sanibel Active Listings

261

Down 17.4% vs. last yearUp 24.9% vs. last month

Sanibel Months of Supply

8.7

Down 43.5% vs. last year

Sanibel Days on Market, Aug–Oct

144

Down 2.0% vs. last year

Captiva Sales, Aug–Oct

5

See all five sales

Captiva Active Listings

69

Down 19.8% vs. last yearUp 9.5% vs. last month

The Sanibel housing market had 261 homes for sale in October 2026, 17.4% fewer than a year earlier. Its August through October median was $925,000, up 15.6%, with single-family homes a larger share of sales. Captiva recorded five sales and had 69 homes for sale, or 19.7 months of supply. Figures are reported separately by island.

Changes compare with September 2026 and October 2025. Three-month figures compare August through October with the same months of 2025. October figures are based on MLS records available as of November 5, 2026.

Source: Florida Gulf Coast MLS. All home types, Sanibel and Captiva reported separately. Market analysis by Michael Davis, Worthington Realty. How we get our numbers

Browse the Market

Sanibel and Captiva Homes for Sale

The newest active listings on Sanibel and Captiva, pulled live from the MLS. Homes on both islands are shown together for browsing, while the prices and market figures on this page stay separate by island. Use the button below the homes to see every listing, then filter by price, beds or home type. Before you make an offer, read what to check before buying or selling.

Save Search

Have a home in mind? Ask about its price, listing history and ownership costs. Ask About a Sanibel or Captiva Property

Before You Decide

What to Check Before Buying or Selling on Sanibel or Captiva

Sanibel is a city with its own building and rental rules. Captiva is unincorporated, so Lee County’s rules apply there. Each record below depends on the specific property, so get it early.

Repairs and rebuilding

For a building in a Special Flood Hazard Area on Sanibel, the City compares repair or improvement costs with 50% of the structure’s market value, not counting land. Damage review includes all labor and materials needed to restore the building to its before-damage condition and uses its market value before the damage; improvement review uses its market value before the improvements. On Captiva, Lee County reviews repair and improvement costs against the structure’s value, not counting land, and damage review includes the full cost of restoring the building to its before-damage condition. Since June 26, 2025, Florida law bars local governments participating in the National Flood Insurance Program from adding separate, completed projects together under a cumulative look-back period. All phases of one project count together, including otherwise countable work that needs no permit. For a damaged building, the review includes the full cost of restoring its before-damage condition, even if only some repairs are planned.

Source: Sanibel flood rules, Lee County cost guidance for Captiva, Florida Statutes 163.31795

Elevation and insurance

On both islands, new homes and substantially damaged or improved homes in flood hazard areas must have the lowest floor at least one foot above base flood elevation, and that height differs by parcel. Confirm the required design elevation with the City or County. Sanibel’s Community Rating System Class 5 rating provides a 25% discount on qualifying National Flood Insurance Program premiums. Ask for the elevation certificate and get flood and wind quotes for the specific property before your inspection period ends.

Source: Sanibel residential checklist, Lee County flood guidance for Captiva, Sanibel flood information

Condo buildings

Ask the association for the building’s repair status, special assessments, reserves, the master insurance policy and the most recent inspection reports. At South Seas on Captiva, confirm which resort amenities require Club Captiva membership or a rental program, and what transfers with the purchase.

Rental use

Most Sanibel homes can be rented only for four consecutive weeks or longer, and a rental needs a City rental dwelling license and business tax receipt. Shorter stays depend on the property’s authorized rental use, so confirm City approval and association rules. On Captiva, rental limits depend on the property’s zoning, County approvals and association documents. Lee County’s Captiva code contains a seven-day minimum and a one-lease-at-a-time restriction for principal and accessory homes on a single RSC-2 lot, an estate residential zoning district. South Seas has separate zoning and approvals. Get written confirmation of the rental restrictions that apply to the property before relying on rental income.

Source: Sanibel rental notice, Lee County Captiva code, Sec. 33-1626

Sanibel and Captiva: what changes when you buy
SanibelCaptiva
Local governmentCity of SanibelUnincorporated Lee County
50% rule reviewCity building departmentLee County building department; confirm how earlier work counts
RentalsMost homes four consecutive weeks or longer, City license and business tax receiptLee County rules and association documents
Drinking waterIsland Water AssociationIsland Water Association
WastewaterCity sewer serviceConfirm the property’s system; the Community Panel reported paused central sewer planning in August 2026
Resort rightsVaries by buildingAt South Seas, confirm Club Captiva and rental program terms

Summarized from the official sources linked above, checked November 1, 2026. Rules change, so confirm them for the specific property. This is general information, not legal or insurance advice.

Market Intelligence

Sanibel and Captiva Housing Market Report, October 2026

From August through October 2026, the Sanibel median sale price for all home types was $925,000, up 15.6% from the same three months of 2025. Captiva recorded 5 sales in those three months.

For sellers: Sanibel had 17.4% fewer homes for sale than a year earlier, and buyers signed 12.3% fewer contracts than a year earlier over the last three months. Months of supply was 8.7, down from 15.4. Captiva had 19.7 months of supply, down from 32.6. Find out what your Sanibel or Captiva home could sell for.

Open a topic for the Sanibel and Captiva numbers, what they mean and recent history. Each topic covers Sanibel first, then Captiva. Time to contract, the re-list rate and asking price come first because sellers ask about them most.

Time to contract

Sanibel homes that sold over the last three months took a median 144 days to go under contract, down from 147

Sanibel

Homes that closed from August through October 2026 spent a median 144 days on market before going under contract, against 147 days a year earlier. October alone had 22 closings at a median 150 days. Days on market runs from the date a listing goes live to the date a contract is accepted, and it starts over when a home is relisted. These figures describe homes that sold, so they do not predict how long a home for sale today will take.

August to October sales144 daysMedian for the 67 Sanibel homes that closed, down from 147.
October sales150 daysMedian for the 22 homes that closed in October, down from 175.
Recent contracts still pending22Pending Sanibel homes whose contract was signed in the 120 days through November 5.

Over the 120 days through November 5, Sanibel homes that sold after relisting spent a median 257 days listed across their attempts, compared with 174 days for first-listing sales. See Re-list rate for the full comparison.

Captiva

The 5 Captiva homes that closed from August through October took from 6 to 207 days to go under contract, with a median of 152. Three Captiva homes were still under contract on November 5 with contracts signed during the previous 120 days.

With five closings, individual sales are more useful for pricing a Captiva property than a headline median sale price.

Closing comes after the contract

A financed sale often takes about four to six weeks to close after a contract is accepted. A cash sale can close faster. Elevation records, insurance, association review, financing and title issues can affect the closing schedule.

Sanibel days on market over the last 13 months, three-month rolling

Sanibel median days on market, three-month rolling, by closing month
Closing monthDaysBar
October 2025147
November 2025130
December 2025118
January 202676
February 202677
March 202692
April 2026110
May 2026103
June 2026103
July 2026103
August 2026131
September 2026166
October 2026144

Each row covers Sanibel homes that closed in that month and the two months before it.

Definitions and methodology: Days on market explained.

Re-list rate

28.7% of Sanibel homes for sale had been listed before in the past year

The Re-list Rate is the share of homes for sale with an expired, withdrawn or terminated listing at the same address in the past 12 months. A sale in between starts a new owner’s history, so it does not count. As of November 5, 78 of 272 Sanibel homes for sale, or 28.7%, had been listed before. Of those, 47.4% came back at least 3% below their earlier asking price.

Re-list Rate28.7%78 of 272 homes for sale, November 5.
Sold on first listing174 daysMedian time to contract, 72 closings over the 120 days through November 5.
Sold after relisting257 daysMedian total days listed across attempts, 18 closings.

Over the 120 days through November 5, homes that sold on their first listing took a median 174 days to go under contract. Homes that sold only after being relisted spent a median 257 days listed in total, and the typical one sold for $80,000 less than its first asking price. The two groups differ in price, condition and seller circumstances, so the data does not show that relisting caused the longer sale or the lower price. Only 18 relisted homes sold in that window, so treat the comparison as a rough guide. The re-list figures use a separate MLS count of 272 Sanibel listings taken November 5. The October month-end total in the cards is 261.

Days on market starts over with each new listing, so a home that looks new to the market may not be. Check the full listing history.

Captiva

As of November 5, 17 of 69 Captiva homes for sale, or 24.6%, had been listed before in the past year. Too few relisted Captiva homes sold to compare selling times.

Definitions and methodology: Why homes get relisted.

Asking price vs. sale

Sanibel sellers received a median 93.7% of their final asking price over three months

Sanibel

Sanibel homes that closed from August through October 2026 sold for a median 93.7% of their final asking price, up from 91.6% a year earlier. October alone was 93.6%. The ratio uses the asking price in place when the contract was signed, so earlier price cuts are not counted. It describes the market as a whole and is not a target for your offer.

The Ask-Bid Gap compares what sellers are asking per square foot with what buyers paid per square foot over the last 120 days. A gap of 10% means sellers are asking 10% more per square foot than buyers have paid. On Sanibel the gap was 15.1% on November 5, and it was smallest under $750,000.

Sanibel Ask-Bid Gap by price range, November 5, 2026
Price rangeAsk-Bid Gap
Under $750,0006.1%
$750,000 to $1.5 million16.9%
$1.5 million to $3 million13.7%
Above $3 million24.2%
This is a market-wide reading, so it does not tell you what discount to expect on a particular home. The homes for sale and the homes that sold are different properties.

Captiva

The 5 Captiva sales closed at between 70.0% and 98.7% of their final asking price, with a median of 92.5%. With so few sales, we do not publish a Captiva Ask-Bid Gap.

Definitions and methodology: Sale-to-list ratio explained.

Prices and the homes that sold

The Sanibel three-month median for all home types was $925,000, 15.6% above last year

Sanibel

Sanibel homes of all types that closed from August through October 2026 sold for a median $925,000, up from $885,000 for July through September and 15.6% above the $800,000 median for the same three months of 2025. The three-month median has been above the same period a year earlier for seven months in a row. Consecutive three-month figures share two months of sales, so the year-over-year streak contains overlapping observations.

Single-family homes accounted for 49 of 67 single-family and condo closings from August through October, compared with 33 of 55 a year earlier. These counts leave out other home types. With fewer than 30 condo sales in three months, we report the combined figure rather than separate home-type medians, and the mix of homes that sold moves it. The three-month median price per square foot, which depends less on home size, was $543, 7.1% above last year.

MLS records show 22 October closings as of November 5, at a median $1,007,500, 35.2% above October 2025. Over the 12 months through October, Sanibel recorded 366 closings, 53.1% more than the 239 in the 12 months before.

Sanibel in October each year, single-month figures
OctoberMedian priceClosingsHomes for saleMonths of supply
2021$939,90029551.1
2022No sales0582.5
2023$1,037,500161795.9
2024$845,50061869.2
2025$745,0002131615.4
2026$1,007,500222618.7

Hurricane Ian struck on September 28, 2022, and Hurricanes Helene and Milton followed in fall 2024. Sanibel recorded no October closings in 2022 and six in 2024. We do not use those years to describe a usual October for the island.

Sanibel three-month median sale price, change from the same period a year earlier

-15%-10%-5%0%+5%+10%+15%+20%+25%Oct 2025: −10.0%Nov 2025: −5.5%Dec 2025: −5.8%Jan 2026: −1.5%Feb 2026: −5.0%Mar 2026: −2.9%Apr 2026: +2.9%May 2026: +13.6%Jun 2026: +11.1%Jul 2026: +20.6%Aug 2026: +4.0%Sep 2026: +6.0%Oct 2026: +15.6%+15.6%−10.0%O'25NDJ'26FMAMJJASO'26
The Sanibel three-month median has been above the same period a year earlier for seven months in a row. Each column compares three months of closings with the same three months a year earlier.
See the numbers
Sanibel three-month median sale price change from a year earlier, by month
MonthChange from a year earlier
Oct 2025−10.0%
Nov 2025−5.5%
Dec 2025−5.8%
Jan 2026−1.5%
Feb 2026−5.0%
Mar 2026−2.9%
Apr 2026+2.9%
May 2026+13.6%
Jun 2026+11.1%
Jul 2026+20.6%
Aug 2026+4.0%
Sep 2026+6.0%
Oct 2026+15.6%

Sanibel three-month median price per square foot, in dollars

This yearSame period a year earlier
450475500525550575600625Oct 2025: 507 (a year earlier: 569)Nov 2025: 494 (a year earlier: 506)Dec 2025: 519 (a year earlier: 502)Jan 2026: 539 (a year earlier: 538)Feb 2026: 588 (a year earlier: 538)Mar 2026: 560 (a year earlier: 582)Apr 2026: 550 (a year earlier: 606)May 2026: 550 (a year earlier: 602)Jun 2026: 560 (a year earlier: 540)Jul 2026: 595 (a year earlier: 458)Aug 2026: 578 (a year earlier: 465)Sep 2026: 563 (a year earlier: 450)Oct 2026: 543 (a year earlier: 507)543O'25NDJ'26FMAMJJASO'26
Price per square foot was $543 for August through October, against $507 a year earlier.
See the numbers
Sanibel three-month median price per square foot by month
MonthThis yearA year earlier
Oct 2025507569
Nov 2025494506
Dec 2025519502
Jan 2026539538
Feb 2026588538
Mar 2026560582
Apr 2026550606
May 2026550602
Jun 2026560540
Jul 2026595458
Aug 2026578465
Sep 2026563450
Oct 2026543507

Captiva

Five Captiva homes sold from August through October 2026. Over the 120 days through November 5, 12 Captiva Island homes sold, from $479,400 to $10 million. Over the 12 months through October, Captiva recorded 44 closings, against 25 in the 12 months before.

Captiva sales, August through October 2026
ClosedHomeSizeSale priceShare of last asking priceDays on market
Aug 7, 2026Single-family home3 bed, 2,530 sq ft$1,750,00070.0%207
Aug 31, 2026Gulf Beach condo3 bed, 1,043 sq ft$710,00098.7%6
Aug 31, 2026South Seas Beach Homes3 bed, 2,038 sq ft$2,830,00094.4%200
Sep 30, 2026South Seas Marina Villas condo2 bed, 861 sq ft$680,00092.5%55
Oct 16, 2026South Seas Tennis Villas condo2 bed, 894 sq ft$479,40087.2%152

Source: FGCMLS, Matrix records for Captiva Island as of November 5, 2026. Upper Captiva (North Captiva) is not included.

With five closings, individual sales are more useful for pricing a Captiva property than a headline median sale price.

Definitions and methodology: Median sale price vs. price per square foot.

Inventory and competition

Of 272 Sanibel listings, 127 passed Worthington’s Competitive Inventory screen

Sanibel

There were 261 Sanibel homes for sale at the end of October, up 24.9% from September and 17.4% fewer than a year earlier. The count has been below the same month a year earlier for nine months in a row. October inventory rose every year from 2021 to 2025, from 55 to 316, and fell this year. Sellers added 87 new listings in October, against 81 a year earlier.

Months of supply was 8.7, up from 6.8 in September and down from 15.4 a year earlier. There were 127 single-family homes for sale, with 6.4 months of supply, and 132 condos, with 13.0 months.

Sanibel homes for sale at month end

This yearSame month a year earlier
150200250300350400450500550Oct 2025: 316 (a year earlier: 186)Nov 2025: 390 (a year earlier: 254)Dec 2025: 426 (a year earlier: 314)Jan 2026: 455 (a year earlier: 393)Feb 2026: 468 (a year earlier: 473)Mar 2026: 435 (a year earlier: 516)Apr 2026: 410 (a year earlier: 503)May 2026: 366 (a year earlier: 441)Jun 2026: 325 (a year earlier: 406)Jul 2026: 263 (a year earlier: 352)Aug 2026: 226 (a year earlier: 303)Sep 2026: 209 (a year earlier: 286)Oct 2026: 261 (a year earlier: 316)261O'25NDJ'26FMAMJJASO'26
The count has been below the same month a year earlier for nine months in a row. It rose from 209 in September to 261 in October.
See the numbers
Sanibel homes for sale by month
MonthThis yearA year earlier
Oct 2025316186
Nov 2025390254
Dec 2025426314
Jan 2026455393
Feb 2026468473
Mar 2026435516
Apr 2026410503
May 2026366441
Jun 2026325406
Jul 2026263352
Aug 2026226303
Sep 2026209286
Oct 2026261316
Published supply8.7 monthsAll active listings against average monthly pending sales, last 12 months.
Competitive Inventory4.2 monthsThose listings against the same average monthly pending sales, about 30 a month.
Passed the screen127Of 272 listings in our November 5 count.

Of the Sanibel listings on November 5, 105 had been on the market 180 days or more, and 41 came back after an earlier listing less than 3% lower. Some listings meet both conditions. Buyers can still choose any of them. The screen leaves them out because of how long they have been listed or how little their price came down.

Our count comes from a separate, address-matched MLS pull, so it differs slightly from the published total of 261.

Captiva

There were 69 Captiva homes for sale at the end of October, 19.8% fewer than a year earlier, with 19.7 months of supply, down from 32.6. Sellers added 11 new listings in October, the same as a year earlier. Of 69 listings in our November 5 count, 36 had been on the market 180 days or more.

Definitions and methodology: Months of supply explained, Competitive Inventory methodology.

Buyer demand

Sanibel buyers signed 57 contracts over three months, 12.3% fewer than a year earlier

Sanibel

Buyers signed 57 Sanibel contracts from August through October 2026, down from 65 in the same three months of 2025. October alone had 19, against 24 a year earlier. Single-family contracts rose to 43 from 36 over the three months, and condo contracts fell to 14 from 27.

Sanibel contracts signed, three-month totals

This yearSame period a year earlier
0102030405060708090100110120130140150Oct 2025: 65 (a year earlier: 33)Nov 2025: 61 (a year earlier: 30)Dec 2025: 62 (a year earlier: 35)Jan 2026: 81 (a year earlier: 52)Feb 2026: 108 (a year earlier: 66)Mar 2026: 147 (a year earlier: 70)Apr 2026: 144 (a year earlier: 73)May 2026: 129 (a year earlier: 75)Jun 2026: 99 (a year earlier: 74)Jul 2026: 80 (a year earlier: 57)Aug 2026: 68 (a year earlier: 57)Sep 2026: 59 (a year earlier: 55)Oct 2026: 57 (a year earlier: 65)57O'25NDJ'26FMAMJJASO'26
Each column counts Sanibel contracts signed over three months, compared with the same three months a year earlier.
See the numbers
Sanibel three-month pending sales by month
MonthThis yearA year earlier
Oct 20256533
Nov 20256130
Dec 20256235
Jan 20268152
Feb 202610866
Mar 202614770
Apr 202614473
May 202612975
Jun 20269974
Jul 20268057
Aug 20266857
Sep 20265955
Oct 20265765
Showings per listing1.7October average, down from 2.3 a year earlier.
Closings67August through October, up 17.5% from a year earlier.
Recent contracts still pending22Pending Sanibel homes whose contract was signed in the 120 days through November 5.

The 22 Sanibel homes still pending on November 5 with contracts signed in the previous 120 days are a point-in-time count, not the number of contracts signed in October. Against the 272 listings in the same count, that is a pending-to-active ratio of 8.1%, or about 8 recent contracts still pending for every 100 homes for sale.

Showing figures come from ShowingTime data in InfoSparks (FGCMLS) and cover listings that use the showing service.

Captiva

Buyers signed 5 Captiva contracts from August through October 2026, against 7 a year earlier. On November 5, 3 Captiva homes were still under contract with contracts signed during the previous 120 days.

Definitions and methodology: Pending sales explained.

Cost to own

Costs to price for a Sanibel or Captiva home before you make an offer

On the islands, insurance, association costs and taxes can matter as much as the loan payment. Get figures for the specific property for each of these:

  • Flood insurance. Standard homeowners policies leave out flood. For a typical one- to four-family home, the National Flood Insurance Program offers coverage up to $250,000 for the building and $100,000 for contents, purchased separately. Condominium association policies have different building limits, so condo buyers should review both the association’s flood policy and their own coverage. Citizens Property Insurance requires flood coverage on applicable personal residential policies with wind coverage in Special Flood Hazard Areas. Outside those areas, the requirement applies in 2026 when the dwelling coverage, called Coverage A, is $400,000 or more, and from January 1, 2027 it applies to applicable new and renewing policies regardless of dwelling value. Condo unit-owner policies are exempt from that Citizens requirement, which does not settle whether a lender or association requires flood coverage. Ask an insurance professional which policy applies and whether more coverage is needed.
  • Wind insurance. Quotes depend on the roof, openings and wind-mitigation features. A wind-mitigation inspection documents the features that can earn discounts.
  • Condo fees and assessments. Ask for the budget, reserves, the master insurance policy and any special assessments, approved or under discussion.
  • Property taxes. After a qualifying change of ownership, a Florida home is generally reassessed at market value the following January 1. Your exemptions and any portability benefit affect the bill, so estimate your own taxes with the Lee County Property Appraiser instead of using the seller’s bill.

Illustrative principal and interest

August to October 2025$3,907 /mo$800,000 at 6.17%
August to October 2026$5,043 /mo$925,000 at 7.24%
Change in estimated principal and interest↑ $1,136 /mo

On the Sanibel three-month median, estimated principal and interest is about $1,136 a month higher than a year ago. Captiva prices vary too widely for a typical figure. This illustration uses each period’s median sale price and the stated mortgage rate. It compares different groups of homes and does not show how the payment on the same home changed.

The payment estimates assume a 30-year fixed loan with 20% down and leave out taxes, insurance and association fees. Rates are U.S. weekly 30-year fixed averages from the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey: 6.17% is the October 30, 2025 reading and 7.24% the October 29, 2026 reading. To add insurance, taxes and association costs for a specific home, use our cost of ownership calculator.
What we’re watching in November

November’s Sanibel three-month all-homes median will be measured against last year’s $815,000

  • Sanibel three-month median. The September through November 2025 median was $815,000. The figure has been above last year for seven months in a row.
  • Sanibel homes for sale. There were 390 Sanibel homes for sale in November 2025. This October’s 261 was 17.4% below a year earlier.
  • Captiva sales. Captiva recorded 9 closings from September through November 2025. We will list the individual sales again.

These are the readings we will check when November data comes in. They are not forecasts.

Pricing Proof

Recently Sold on Sanibel and Captiva

Closings on Sanibel and Captiva over the last six months, the clearest read on what buyers are paying. When you compare sales, match condition and completed work as well as size and location. On Captiva, look at individual sales, since a month can have only one or two.

Save Search

Keeping an eye on your home’s value?

Follow recent sales near your home, and keep track of insurance, property taxes and association costs. When your plans change, request a review of your address.

Worthington Realty, Inc.

Send us a question

Goes to a Worthington agent at Worthington Realty, Inc. You’ll hear back personally within one business day.

Home Value

Sanibel and Captiva Home Values: What Is Your Home Worth?

Share your address and a Worthington agent will review recent comparable sales, send a pricing range, and explain what it means for your timing. Not ready for a value review? You can simply ask a question.

You’ll hear back personally within one business day, and you don’t need to be ready to list.

Living Here

Living on Sanibel and Captiva

A practical orientation for anyone weighing a purchase, including owners who will be away part of the year.

Sanibel is a city reached by the Sanibel Causeway. A standard two-axle toll is $6 with an accepted transponder linked to a prepaid account and $9 billed by plate, charged toward Sanibel, according to Lee County. Homes range from Gulf-front and near-beach condos to inland single-family homes and waterfront homes on the bay and canals. Island Water Association supplies drinking water, and the City runs sewer service.

Captiva sits north of Sanibel across Blind Pass and is reached through Sanibel, so the same toll applies. It is unincorporated Lee County. The first distinction for buyers is South Seas, the resort at the north end, against Captiva Village and the rest of the island. South Seas has reopened lodging and some amenities while redevelopment continues, according to its own update. In its August 18, 2026 minutes, the Captiva Community Panel reported that central sewer planning remained paused, so confirm how a property handles wastewater. Upper Captiva, also called North Captiva, has no road connection, is reached by boat or private plane and is not part of the Captiva figures on this page.

Many owners on both islands live elsewhere part of the year. Plan for storm preparation, a local contact and how the property will be checked while you are away.

Street map of Southwest Florida showing Fort Myers, Cape Coral, Estero, Bonita Springs and Naples Lee & Collier · FEMA flood map
Flood risk

Check a Sanibel or Captiva address’s flood zone

Flood zones and required elevations differ by parcel on both islands. Look up the FEMA flood zone for any address, then ask for the elevation certificate and an insurance quote before you make an offer.

Open the flood zone lookup →
Questions & Answers

Sanibel and Captiva Buying and Selling Questions

Selling

What could my Sanibel or Captiva home sell for?

Sanibel homes that closed from August through October 2026 sold for a median $925,000 across all home types. Captiva had 5 sales in those months, from $479,400 to $2.83 million, so a Captiva value rests on the closest individual sales. On both islands, condition, elevation and completed repairs matter. Request a home value review.

How long are homes taking to sell on Sanibel and Captiva?

Sanibel homes that closed from August through October 2026 went under contract in a median 144 days, down from 147 a year earlier. The 5 Captiva sales in those months took from 6 to 207 days. Days on market starts over when a home is relisted, so check the full listing history.

Is Sanibel a buyer’s or seller’s market right now?

Sanibel’s October 2026 supply figures lean toward buyers. Overall supply was 8.7 months, above the four to six months usually read as balanced, and down from 15.4 a year earlier. Single-family homes had 6.4 months and condos 13.0. These figures describe broad conditions. Use recent sales, condition and current competition to price a particular home or offer.

Why doesn’t this page show a Captiva median price?

Captiva recorded five sales from August through October 2026, from $479,400 to $2.83 million. With so few sales, the mix of properties can move a median sharply, so this page lists each sale instead. When pricing a Captiva home, compare individual sales of similar homes.

Can I buy or sell a Sanibel or Captiva home while living out of state?

Yes. Many island owners live elsewhere, and many steps can be handled remotely. Confirm signing, notarization and lender requirements with the title company or closing attorney. Sellers can start by sending the address, timing and any completed or unfinished work through our home value review.

Buying

How could the FEMA 50% rule affect a Sanibel or Captiva property?

When repair or improvement costs reach 50% of the building’s value, the building must meet current flood rules, which can mean elevating or rebuilding. The rule applies to buildings in a Special Flood Hazard Area. Since June 26, 2025, Florida law bars adding separate, completed projects together under a cumulative look-back period. All phases of one project still count together, and for a damaged building the review includes the full cost of restoring it, even if only some repairs are planned.

What should I check about insurance, building repairs and condo assessments on Sanibel or Captiva?

Get flood and wind quotes for the specific property before your inspection period ends. For a condo, review the association’s flood and master policies, reserves, repair status and any special assessments, along with your own coverage. Sanibel’s flood rating provides a 25% discount on qualifying National Flood Insurance Program premiums. Ask for the elevation certificate and permit history for any property.

Where do I check permits and elevation records for a Sanibel home versus a Captiva home?

Different governments keep them. Sanibel is a city: existing permits are with the City’s Building Department, and its flood information page links to a map that shows flood zones and elevation certificates where available. Captiva is in unincorporated Lee County, so permits are with Lee County Community Development, which also has an elevation certificate search. On either island, ask the seller for the elevation certificate, the permit history and any storm claims, and find values for both islands on the Lee County Property Appraiser site.

What comes with a condo at South Seas on Captiva?

It depends on the unit’s condominium association and any resort, club membership or rental program agreements, so read those documents rather than relying on the listing. Get written confirmation of which amenities owners and their renters can use, the fees and conditions, how renting through the resort differs from renting privately, and what is open now. South Seas posts resort operating updates, which do not set any one unit’s rights.

Owning

How do I check rental rules for a Sanibel or Captiva property?

Most Sanibel homes can be rented only for four consecutive weeks or longer, with a City rental dwelling license and business tax receipt. Shorter stays depend on the property’s authorized use. On Captiva, check the property’s zoning, County approvals and association documents. Lee County’s Captiva code contains a seven-day restriction for homes on RSC-2 lots. That provision does not establish one minimum stay for every Captiva property. Get written confirmation of the rental restrictions that apply before buying. Association rules on either island can be stricter. See Sanibel’s rental notice.

Nearby Markets

Explore other Southwest Florida markets

Each market has its own homes for sale, recent sales and monthly market update.

Talk through the Sanibel and Captiva markets with a local expert

What could your Sanibel or Captiva home sell for? Send the address, which island, your timing and any completed or unfinished work. We review comparable sales, current competition and a suggested asking range with you.

Worthington Realty, Inc. · (239) 437-3334 · 8880 Gladiolus Drive, Suite 102, Fort Myers, FL 33908. Market data from the Florida Gulf Coast MLS, reflecting records available as of November 5, 2026. Records can be added or corrected after that date. Listing data is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. How we get our numbers. Based on information from the Florida Gulf Coast Multiple Listing Service, Inc. for the period January 1, 2021 through October 31, 2026.