If you are searching for Fort Myers sold homes 500k to 750k, this page shows what buyers actually paid, which communities are producing the most closings, and what to expect when you start making offers.
Key Takeaways
- 288 homes closed in this price range in the last 120 days, roughly 72 per month
- Median sold price: $590,000 at $275 per square foot and 2,224 square feet
- Homes are selling at 96.4% of asking price with a 55-day median days on market
- The most common configuration is a 3-bedroom or 3-bedroom-plus-den home built around 2005
- The Plantation, Pelican Preserve, and Gateway lead all communities in closed sales volume
Fort Myers Sold Homes $500k to 750k: Recent Closings
The homes below are recently closed sales at this price point. These are completed transactions. Every result shown represents a home that has already closed. This gallery updates daily with new closed sales reported through the Florida Gulf Coast MLS. The homes shown reflect the most recent 30 days of closed transactions as of today. Use them to see what buyers are actually paying, which communities are moving, and how quickly homes in this tier go under contract.
This Price Range Is Where Fort Myers Real Estate Moves
In the last 120 days, 288 homes closed in Fort Myers between $500,000 and $750,000. That works out to roughly 72 transactions per month, a pace that reflects genuine buyer demand at this price point. For a broader look at where the Fort Myers market stands right now, see our Fort Myers Housing Market Report — April 2026.
The median sold price lands at $590,000. Buyers are paying a median of $275 per square foot and closing on homes with a median of 2,224 square feet. Most of these homes were built around 2005. That means established communities with mature landscaping, built-out amenities, and infrastructure that newer developments are still assembling.
Sellers are receiving 96.4 cents on the dollar at the median. The median days on market sits at 55 days. Well-priced homes in the right communities close faster than that.
What Is the Monthly Payment on a $590,000 Home in Fort Myers?
Use the calculator below to run your own numbers. At the median sold price with 20 percent down and current rates, most buyers in this tier are looking at a payment in the mid-to-upper $2,000s per month before taxes and insurance.
The Typical Buyer at This Price Point Wants Space and a Den
Three-bedroom homes account for the largest share of closings in this tier. Three-bedroom-plus-den homes are nearly as common. Together, those two configurations represent more than 60 percent of all closings. Four-bedroom homes make up most of the remainder.
The den is one of the most-searched filters on Zillow for buyers in this range. It is often the first feature that separates a home that sells in 30 days from one that sits for 90. Buyers here are relocating professionals, retirees looking for a home office and a guest room, and families trading up who have decided exactly what they want.
Five Communities Driving Fort Myers Sold Homes $500k to 750k
Certain communities dominate the closed sales data in this tier. If you are narrowing your search, these are the neighborhoods worth studying first.
The Plantation — 21 Closings
Built by Pulte beginning in 2006, The Plantation is structured around two distinct neighborhoods. Somerset is oriented around the optional 18-hole Hurdzan-Fry championship course, a private dining culture, and a traditional club atmosphere. Bridgetown focuses on resort recreation. The 25,000-square-foot Great House clubhouse, resort pool, tennis, and pickleball anchor that neighborhood, with no golf requirement. Buyers choose their lifestyle within the same gates. The Plantation is all-ages and sits six miles from RSW Airport on the Treeline Avenue corridor.
Learn more about The Plantation and search available homes for sale.
Pelican Preserve — 21 Closings
One of Southwest Florida’s most complete 55-plus communities, built on more than 1,100 acres off Colonial Boulevard near I-75. The 70,000-square-foot Plaza del Sol Town Center includes a 99-seat theater, indoor walking track, arts studios, woodshop, and outdoor amphitheater. The community has 38 acres of nature preserves and more than 30 resident-led clubs. Golf is optional, with a 27-hole Chip Powell-designed course available through an equity membership. For the active-adult buyer, Pelican Preserve sets the benchmark for amenity depth in Fort Myers.
Learn more about Pelican Preserve and search available homes for sale.
Gateway — 18 Closings
A master-planned community built around a Tom Fazio-designed golf course, Gateway offers larger homes at a lower price per square foot than most comparable communities on the Treeline corridor. The value comes with a location tradeoff. Gateway sits east of the airport on the Daniels Parkway corridor, away from waterfront and beach routes but convenient to RSW, I-75, and Lee County’s employment base.
Timber Creek — 11 Closings
Lennar’s newest Fort Myers master-planned community, built between 2020 and 2025 on 655 acres near Daniels Parkway and I-75, draws buyers who want modern construction with no golf obligation. Lennar’s Everything’s Included homes come with quartz counters and smart home technology standard. The recreation focus is sports: full indoor basketball courts, resort pool, pickleball, and tennis.
Learn more about Timber Creek and search available homes for sale.
Verandah — 11 Closings
Verandah sits along the Orange River in east Fort Myers on 1,456 acres, with nine miles of trails, kayaking and river access, and two-thirds of the land preserved as green space. Two optional championship golf courses anchor the community: the Bob Cupp-designed Old Orange and the Jack Nicklaus II-designed Whispering Oak. It is Fort Myers’ only riverfront golf community and the most nature-focused setting on this list.
Learn more about Verandah and search available homes for sale.
Other communities active in this price range include Lexington Country Club (bundled golf, dual-village layout, with HealthPark Medical Center across the street), Colonial Country Club, Arborwood Preserve, and Gulf Harbour Yacht and Country Club (deep-water marina with direct Gulf access on the Caloosahatchee River).
See What Is Available Right Now
Ready to see active listings in this price range? Find homes for sale across Fort Myers or search all of Southwest Florida. When you find something worth talking about, tell us what you are looking for and we will take it from there.
Already Own a Home in Fort Myers?
Many buyers in this price range are also selling. If you own a home in Fort Myers and want to know what it is worth in today’s market, get a free market value estimate below. No obligation, no pressure.
Sales data reflects closed residential transactions in Fort Myers, Florida reported through the Florida Gulf Coast MLS. Data covers the 120-day period ending April 13, 2026. Median figures are used throughout to reduce the effect of outlying sales on reported results.
