Buying a home in Fort Myers isn’t only about the property itself. The neighborhood you choose shapes your daily routine, from the places you visit on weekends to the views you see on your morning walk. Fort Myers offers a wide range of communities, each with its own mix of amenities, housing styles, and price points.
If you’re moving from out of town, it can be tough to know where to start. That’s why we’ve gathered a look at some of the most notable neighborhoods in the area.
Key Takeaways (TL;DR)
- Fort Myers neighborhoods include golf, resort-style, urban, and island living options.
- Communities vary widely in amenities, housing styles, and price points.
- Popular names include Colonial Country Club, Pelican Preserve, Lexington, Paseo, Cypress Lake, Timber Creek, and WildBlue.
- Buyers can also explore downtown condos or island living on Sanibel, Captiva, and Fort Myers Beach.
Fort Myers Neighborhoods Near Parks and Preserves
Fort Myers is home to communities that put nature close at hand.
Colonial Country Club is a gated neighborhood with villas, condos, and single-family homes. Its highlight is proximity to the Six Mile Cypress Slough Preserve, a 3,500-acre wetland with boardwalk trails and wildlife viewing. Median home prices here hover around $355,000, and the community balances convenience with natural beauty.
Cypress Lake has a suburban setting with access to nearby golf clubs and one of the best outdoor amenities in Fort Myers—Lakes Park. This local favorite offers walking trails, gardens, playgrounds, and seasonal farmers markets. Home prices in Cypress Lake typically range from about $175,000 to $800,000, giving buyers plenty of options.
For those who want a blend of city convenience and access to outdoor space, both Colonial and Cypress Lake make strong choices.
Fort Myers Communities with Resort-Style Amenities
Some Fort Myers neighborhoods are built for active living, where amenities extend beyond your front door.
Pelican Preserve includes resort-style recreation centers, golf, and miles of nature trails. Its design weaves together activity and relaxation, with median sale prices around $505,000.
Lexington Country Club, located in South Fort Myers, combines golf, social clubs, and resort-style amenities. With condos, villas, and single-family homes, prices typically range from the mid-$300,000s to over $1,000,000.
Crown Colony spans 400 acres and features a private golf course, clubhouse events, and a quiet, upscale setting. Homes often list between $600,000 and $1.25 million.
Esplanade Lake Club adds a waterfront lifestyle to the resort feel, with Tuscan- and California-inspired architecture and prices that stretch from $600,000 to more than $2 million.
Timber Creek is one of Fort Myers’ newer master-planned communities. It offers pools, sports courts, a clubhouse, and modern designs for both townhomes and single-family residences. Prices start in the $300,000s, making it an accessible option for those seeking the resort-style experience.
Neighborhoods with Downtown Energy
Downtown Fort Myers—also called the River District—offers a very different lifestyle. Here, high-rise condos and loft-style apartments overlook the Caloosahatchee River, and historic properties line walkable streets.
Living downtown means being steps from art galleries, live music, restaurants, and festivals. Prices begin in the $300,000s and climb for luxury waterfront units. For those who want culture and convenience within reach, the River District delivers.
Waterfront and Island Living Near Fort Myers
Waterfront living is part of what defines Southwest Florida, and several communities make it possible.
Fort Myers Beach continues to rebuild after Hurricane Ian. Buyers are watching closely as new construction and redevelopment bring energy back to the shoreline. Direct beach access and investment potential make this area one to watch.
Sanibel and Captiva Islands remain popular for their exclusivity, natural landscapes, and slower pace. These islands typically carry higher price points, with homes ranging from coastal cottages to multi-million-dollar estates.
WildBlue, east of I-75, offers luxury lakeside living with custom homes on oversized lots. Residents enjoy boating, water sports, and modern amenities in a gated setting. Prices here stretch into the multi-million dollar range, making it one of the most prestigious new communities in the region.
FAQs About Fort Myers Neighborhoods
Buyers can find condos, villas, townhomes, and single-family homes, with prices starting around $175,000 and climbing into the multi-millions for waterfront and luxury properties.
Communities like Pelican Preserve, Lexington Country Club, Crown Colony, Esplanade Lake Club, and Timber Creek all include pools, golf, clubhouses, and organized social activities.
The River District combines historic architecture with new development. It offers walkability, cultural events, and riverfront views, making it stand out from gated suburban neighborhoods.
Recovery is ongoing, but new development is steadily bringing back interest. Buyers are drawn to the mix of beachfront living and the potential for long-term growth.
Many are attracted by the value compared to other Florida markets, the year-round sunshine, and the coastal lifestyle. Learn more in our blog on why people keep moving to Florida.
Final Thoughts
Fort Myers offers something for nearly every type of buyer. From suburban neighborhoods like Cypress Lake to resort-style communities such as Pelican Preserve, Timber Creek, and Lexington, and from the energy of downtown to the exclusivity of Sanibel and WildBlue, the options are wide and varied.
If you’re ready to explore, start by browsing current Fort Myers homes for sale or download our Home Buying Guide. Then let’s talk about the neighborhoods that make the most sense for your goals.
Most homeowners feel overwhelmed when it’s time to move. At Worthington Realty, we provide personalized guidance and clear communication so that you feel heard, valued, and confident in your decisions.
Let’s Make Your Next Move Simple
