Buying a home is a big decision, and in Fort Myers, it’s not just about the house itself. It’s about finding a neighborhood that fits your life.
If you’re moving here from out of town, it’s hard to know where to start. Everyone has an opinion, and every neighborhood looks great online. But you’re not just choosing a house. You’re choosing the next chapter of your life.
Whether you’re moving with kids, planning for retirement, or just starting out, choosing the right area can shape your entire experience of living here. Fort Myers offers a wide range of neighborhoods, each with its own vibe, price range, and lifestyle fit. But how do you know which one is right for you?
That’s where this guide comes in. We’ve pulled together the most up-to-date insights, from real estate data to real conversations happening right now, to help you buy with clarity and confidence.
Best Neighborhoods in Fort Myers Near Schools and Parks
View homes for sale in Cypress Lake: Cypress Lake offers a suburban feel and access to several well-known schools, including Cypress Lake Middle, High, and Canterbury School. The area also features nearby golf clubs and a range of home prices from $175,000 to $800,000.
View homes for sale in Colonial Country Club: This peaceful, gated golf community features scenic surroundings and easy access to Six Mile Cypress Slough Preserve. With a variety of housing types including villas, condos, and single-family homes, it appeals to buyers looking for flexible living options. Median home price: $355,000.
View homes for sale in Pelican Preserve: Pelican Preserve, while originally designed for retirees, includes resort-style amenities, nature trails, and proximity to shopping centers. Its community layout and recreation options attract a wide range of buyers. Median sale price: $505,000.
Best Neighborhoods in Fort Myers for Laid-Back, Resort-Style Living
View homes for sale in Lexington Country Club: This private, gated golf community in South Fort Myers offers a strong sense of connection and resort-style amenities. With a mix of condos, villas, and single-family homes, it’s popular with buyers who enjoy golf, social clubs, and easy access to the beach. Prices typically range from the mid-$300,000s to over $1,000,000.
View homes for sale in Crown Colony: Spanning 400 acres and featuring a private golf course, Crown Colony offers a quiet lifestyle with clubhouse events, social clubs, and close proximity to the Gulf Coast. Homes range from $600,000 to $1.25 million.
View homes for sale in Esplanade Lake Club: With lakeside living and California- and Tuscan-inspired villas, this gated community offers peace, beauty, and easy access to shopping and dining. Price range: $600,000 to over $2 million.
Best Neighborhoods in Fort Myers for Easy Commutes
View homes for sale in Downtown Fort Myers: Historic charm, walkability, and nightlife come together in the River District. Art galleries, restaurants, and events keep things social. With high-rise condos and loft-style housing, it’s a great fit for those who want city energy at a slower pace. Median price: $429,500.
View homes for sale in Paseo: This resort-style community offers pools, a village center, and clubs that make it feel like a permanent vacation. Homes range from $300,000 to $1.5 million and include townhomes, villas, and single-family homes.
View homes for sale in Watermark: Ideal for first-time buyers, Watermark offers waterfront views, new construction, and modern homes in the $400,000 to $600,000 range. Great for commuters with easy access to I-75. Read more about Colonial’s Diverging Diamond Interchange here.
Trending Areas for Island Life
View homes for sale in Fort Myers Beach: Recovering from Hurricane Ian, this area is seeing renewed interest thanks to beachfront access and new development.
View homes for sale on Sanibel & Captiva Islands: For those seeking exclusivity, nature, and a slower pace, these islands continue to be popular, though they come at a higher price point.
What Locals Are Saying
“Cypress Lake has great schools, a calm atmosphere, and it’s close to everything.”
“Downtown’s come alive—great food and events every weekend.”
“Pelican Preserve feels like a resort. I play golf in the morning and walk the trails in the evening. It’s exactly the kind of pace I was looking for.”
Here’s How We Help:
- Get clear on what matters most to you
- Explore neighborhoods that match your lifestyle
- Buy with confidence, knowing you chose well
The Honest Answer
There’s no one-size-fits-all when it comes to Fort Myers real estate. But when you know what you’re looking for, and what each neighborhood offers, you’re not just buying a house. You’re choosing how you want to live.
Let’s make sure your next home feels like the right fit, neighborhood and all.
Schedule a quick conversation, or browse available homes in these neighborhoods now.
Want help navigating the full process? Our Home Buying Guide is a simple, practical resource you can use to make every step easier—from first showing to final signature.
Still deciding if Fort Myers is your kind of place? You might enjoy this local perspective: Why some are calling it the Brooklyn of the Gulf Coast.
